A minimum of 5 matches is required for the Match Power list
| #1 | Jason Nolf (Penn State) | 5.259 |
| #2 | Zain Retherford (Penn State) | 5.250 |
| #3 | Bo Nickal (Penn State) | 4.963 |
| #4 | Gabe Dean (Cornell) | 4.914 |
| #5 | Jacobe Smith (Oklahoma State) | 4.667 |
| #6 | Seth Gross (South Dakota State) | 4.611 |
| #7 | Thomas Gilman (Iowa) | 4.576 |
| #8 | Kyle Snyder (Ohio State) | 4.529 |
| #9 | Sean Hosford (Missouri) | 4.500 |
| #10 | Michael Hughes (Hofstra) | 4.419 |